Even in today's Evening Herald magazine they slate Charlie Casanova. This being during an interview with the star! So to explain what's going 'wrong' here are ten reasons:
1. They've never seen anything like it before.
The reason why rubbish like Parked/Sensation/Savage get good reviews by our critics is because they've seen this stuff already in other movies. It's familiar and they feel comfortable watching it.
2. It's technically sh-t!
How anyone expected a €1,000 movie to look better is a puzzle? Unlike crap like Anton the filmmakers here didn't try to piss higher than the urinal.
3. The characters are horrible
I can understand this one. There are no likeable characters here so it would turn audiences off.
4. There's no plot
Actually there is, but it's not using the routine 3-act structure. But even so, I did not find this movie confusing.
5. The director's a prat
Maybe he is I don't know. But here's a question: would you rather see a movie from this interesting director or a movie from yet another smug, bearded, film-school grad, with some shit overrated short film?
6. There's no backstory
Like Anton this one is a character piece and the other actors play background roles. That gives the movie little depth and is a flaw.
7. It's too fast
I can't think of any other Irish movie so fast-paced as this? However, compared with sh-t like Parked where every scene is dragged out and then they cut to an establishing shot this movie was a breath of fresh air.
8. It's ugly/vulgar/nasty
So what? Who says cinema needs to be audience-pleasing and safe. We've produced enough lame crap already in this country. More movies with an edge like this please.
9. It's just a bad movie
What's good/bad is subjective. We've lots of 'good' films from 'good' directors and they are just sh-t. But no-one will say this because they won stupid IFTA awards. Charlie Casanova is more of an 'interesting' movie than a bad one. Real film fans prefer 'interesting' movies. Casual movie fans prefer 'good' ones.
10. It doesn't make sense
It does actually. A guy goes beserk and offs the working class based on a deck of cards. He's involved with his friends and their wives. Maybe the critics find a middle-class guy attacking tracksuited scumbags silly? I don't!
Nah, it's just shit.
ReplyDelete